Milestone-Proposal:RCA Radio Central

From IEEE Milestones Wiki
Revision as of 15:02, 4 February 2019 by Administrator1 (talk | contribs)
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.


To see comments, or add a comment to this discussion, click here.

Docket #:2018-15

This Proposal has been approved, and is now a Milestone


To the proposer’s knowledge, is this achievement subject to litigation? No

Is the achievement you are proposing more than 25 years old? Yes

Is the achievement you are proposing within IEEE’s designated fields as defined by IEEE Bylaw I-104.11, namely: Engineering, Computer Sciences and Information Technology, Physical Sciences, Biological and Medical Sciences, Mathematics, Technical Communications, Education, Management, and Law and Policy. Yes

Did the achievement provide a meaningful benefit for humanity? Yes

Was it of at least regional importance? Yes

Has an IEEE Organizational Unit agreed to pay for the milestone plaque(s)? Yes

Has an IEEE Organizational Unit agreed to arrange the dedication ceremony? Yes

Has the IEEE Section in which the milestone is located agreed to take responsibility for the plaque after it is dedicated? Yes

Has the owner of the site agreed to have it designated as an IEEE Milestone? Yes


Year or range of years in which the achievement occurred:

1921-1977

Title of the proposed milestone:

RCA Radio Central, 1921-1977

Plaque citation summarizing the achievement and its significance:

RCA Radio Central: November 5, 1921, – December 13, 1977

On November 5th, 1921, President Harding’s telegraphic transoceanic message inaugurated the world’s most powerful transoceanic radio facility, RCA Radio Central on more than 7000 acres at Rocky Point and Riverhead, NY. Its Alexanderson 220KW, 18.3KHz transmitters and Beverage long-wire receiving antennas provided reliable worldwide radio communications and its research laboratory developed diversity radio reception, rhombic and folded-wave antennas, the first transoceanic single side-band channels and commercial FAX service.

200-250 word abstract describing the significance of the technical achievement being proposed, the person(s) involved, historical context, humanitarian and social impact, as well as any possible controversies the advocate might need to review.


IEEE technical societies and technical councils within whose fields of interest the Milestone proposal resides.


In what IEEE section(s) does it reside?

Long Island Section

IEEE Organizational Unit(s) which have agreed to sponsor the Milestone:

IEEE Organizational Unit(s) paying for milestone plaque(s):

Unit: Long Island Section
Senior Officer Name: Lou D'Onofrio

IEEE Organizational Unit(s) arranging the dedication ceremony:

Unit: Long Island Section
Senior Officer Name: {{{Senior officer name}}}

IEEE section(s) monitoring the plaque(s):

IEEE Section: Long Island Section
IEEE Section Chair name: {{{Section chair name}}}

Milestone proposer(s):

Proposer name: Mort Hans
Proposer email: Proposer's email masked to public

Please note: your email address and contact information will be masked on the website for privacy reasons. Only IEEE History Center Staff will be able to view the email address.

Street address(es) and GPS coordinates in decimal form of the intended milestone plaque site(s):

Rocky Point Union School District 90 Rocky Point - Yaphank Road Rocky Point, NY 11778 Coordinates: 40.896680, -72.945430

Describe briefly the intended site(s) of the milestone plaque(s). The intended site(s) must have a direct connection with the achievement (e.g. where developed, invented, tested, demonstrated, installed, or operated, etc.). A museum where a device or example of the technology is displayed, or the university where the inventor studied, are not, in themselves, sufficient connection for a milestone plaque.

Please give the address(es) of the plaque site(s) (GPS coordinates if you have them). Also please give the details of the mounting, i.e. on the outside of the building, in the ground floor entrance hall, on a plinth on the grounds, etc. If visitors to the plaque site will need to go through security, or make an appointment, please give the contact information visitors will need. The intended site is in a building of the Rocky Point Union School District that is on the grounds of the former RCA Radio Central facility.

Are the original buildings extant?

Only remnants of the original antenna transmission towers at the Rocky Point and receiving antenna towers at the Riverhead sites remain. The former sites of key buildings at both locations are shown on the maps that are included as part of this proposal.

Details of the plaque mounting:

To be provided.

How is the site protected/secured, and in what ways is it accessible to the public?

To be provided.

Who is the present owner of the site(s)?

The Rocky Point Union Free School District, 90 Rocky Point - Yaphank Road, Rocky Point, NY 11778.

What is the historical significance of the work (its technological, scientific, or social importance)? If personal names are included in citation, include justification here. (see section 6 of Milestone Guidelines)

To understand the historical significance of the work carried out over 56 years at the RCA Radio Central facilities, one must first consider its unusual origin (Ref. 19). It marked the first and only formation of a business at the instigation of the War Department. Its origin was in the culmination of United States political interest at the end of World War I to maintain its dominance in international communications and the Navy Department’s goal of ensuring reliable communications with its worldwide fleet operations.

Up to the beginning of World War I, the primary wireless company in the United States was the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Company of America. Its primary source of business was the marine message service that provided both commercial and marine safety services for ships and had achieved international significance. Although incorporated in New Jersey and known as American Marconi, the company could not demonstrate that it was not under British foreign control. Consequently, its operations were taken over by the Navy. By the end of the war, the company was producing equipment for the Navy and the Navy had to relinquish all of the Marconi facilities or the government had to change the law so that it could remain in the commercial message business. The proposed solution was to have the British interests in Marconi purchased by an American company. The new company was incorporated in the state of Delaware on October 19, 1919 as the Radio Corporation of America (RCA). RCA received the American Marconi patents, its high powered stations and its contract with the U.S. Shipping Board for the maintenance on 400 of its ships. Of particular interest to the United States were three of the articles of incorporation. One prohibited the election of directors who were not U.S. citizens. Another restricted to 20% the amount of stock that could be owned by a foreigner. The third permitted participation by the United States government in the administration of the corporation’s business. Edward Nally, who had been President of American Marconi was elected Chairman of the Board and David Sarnoff who succeeded him, became Managing Director. The new company’s primary business objectives at its founding were to be the dominant provider of worldwide wireless commercial communications, which at the time was American Marconi a subsidiary of the British Marconi Company, to provide equipment and services for seagoing vessels and to compete with the undersea cables by offering improved reliability. To provide the worldwide service the company soon undertook a massive project to build a "Radio Central" transmitter center at Rocky Point, Long Island, New York, which together with its receiving station at Riverhead and central office in New York City would achieve the vision of communication engineers to transmit messages to all points of the world from a single centrally located source. Although triode versions of vacuum tubes were already being used by ham radio operators, experimenters and researchers as oscillators and amplifiers at the lower short wave frequencies, the very low frequencies were being used at a number of stations to provide reliable higher power transmissions utilizing Alexanderson Alternators. In a 1923 paper (Ref.5) Alexanderson co-authored, he stated the advantages of long wave radio propagation compared with that of short waves. As part of the formation of RCA, ownership of the two high power Alexanderson Alternators that had been ordered by Marconi was transferred to RCA and became the basis of the planned global reach employing twelve directional transmitters planned for Radio Central.

The long antennas required for the very low frequency operation of the Alexanderson alternator operation at 18.3KHz and the long wire Beverage antenna for receiving utilized two sites, 7000 acres at Rocky Point and 2000 acres at Riverhead on Long Island, NY (Fig. 1). Today, the original sites remain as preserves, the 6000 acre Rocky Point State Pine Barrens at Rocky Point and the 2700 acre David A. Sarnoff Preserve at Riverhead. Only remnants of the original massive steel antenna towers remain.

Figure 1. Rocky Point and Riverhead Locations

The inauguration of RCA Radio Central (Ref.1) occurred on November 5th, 1921 when President Harding pressed a button in the White House sending a worldwide telegraphic message of friendship over RCA Radio Central’s relay network to activate the first of the two 200KW Alexanderson alternators at Rocky Point. Acknowledgements of the transmission, which marked the first radio message sent by a president, were received from 17 countries, including Japan and Australia at the Riverhead receiving facility. For more than 70 years RCA Radio Central not only provided reliable world-wide radio communications but developed diversity radio reception, performed the first high-power vacuum tube experiments, established the first transoceanic SSB channels, developed rhombic and folded-dipoles antennas and the first transoceanic FAX service.

What obstacles (technical, political, geographic) needed to be overcome?

Technical

The major problem associated with the selection of the Rocky Hill site for the transmitters was the composition of the ground soil which consisting primarily of quartz sand has a very high resistance. The problem was solved, as stated earlier, by building a huge counterpoise ground for the VLF antennas that consisted of buried wires, the equivalent of a copper plate 2000 feet wide and three miles long. Each wire length was separated by 10 feet and buried 15-20 inches below ground (Ref. 5, p697) thus making the antennas independent of soil resistance. The Beverage wave antennas used at Riverhead required high resistance grounds so that the ground resistance was not a problem.

Another problem with the long lengths of the antennas and the distant locations of the tuning coils was the power losses in the transmission wires from the alternators to the antennas. The problem was solved with the design of a transmission line for flat top antennas initially and then later applied to HF antennas by Philip Carter who had worked with Beverage at Riverhead.

The problem of ice forming on the antenna wires was addressed by a switching circuit that disconnected the wires from the alternators and connected them to electrical power circuits that provided sufficient current to melt the ice (Ref. 5).

The rapid development of vacuum tubes, the shift to the higher short-wave frequencies that were taking place and the high cost of the Alexanderson alternators might well have brought the operation to an early demise had RCA not realized that alternators in just a few years had become obsolete.

Political

The creation of the RCA Radio Central facility was the culmination of United States political interest at the end of World War I to maintain dominance in international communications and the Navy Department’s goal of ensuring reliable communications with its worldwide fleet operations.

Up to the beginning of World War I, the primary wireless company in the United States was the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Company of America. Its primary source of business was the marine message service that provided both commercial and marine safety services for ships and had achieved international significance. Although incorporated in New Jersey and known as American Marconi, the company could not demonstrate that it was not under British foreign control. Consequently, its operations were taken over by the Navy. By the end of the war, the company was producing equipment for the Navy and the Navy had to relinquish all of the Marconi facilities or the government had to change the law so that it could remain in the commercial message business.

The solution (Ref.4) was to have the British interests in Marconi purchased by an American company. At the time (1919), Marconi was negotiating with General Electric for the exclusive use of the Alexanderson alternator offering to purchase 24 of the very high power (212KW) very low frequency (17.2 KHz) Alexanderson inverters. General Electric wanted to lease them so Marconi countered with an offer of an additional million dollars to defray General Electric’s development costs. Having a foreign controlled company owning the transmitters was unacceptable to the Navy so the offer to have the British interests in Marconi purchased by an American company was proposed, but the question of what to do with the GE inverters was a major problem since GE had already spent $1 million in their development. At a Navy Department meeting, it was suggested that General Electric establish an international communications system based on the long distance capability of the high power, very low frequency alternators. It was arranged for GE to start a new company that would take over the assets of the British controlled Marconi Company, which included the wireless stations held by the Navy. The new company was incorporated in 1919 as the Radio Corporation of America RCA).

RCA received the American Marconi patents, its high-powered stations and its contract with the U.S. Shipping Board for the maintenance on 400 of its ships. Of particular interest to the United States were three of the articles of incorporation. One prohibited the election of directors who were not U.S. citizens. A second article restricted to 20% the amount of stock that could be owned by a foreigner. And a third article, permitted participation by the United States government in the administration of the corporation’s business. Edward Nally, who had been President of American Marconi was elected Chairman of the Board and David Sarnoff who succeeded him, became Managing Director.

Geographic

In 1920 RCA had purchased the Riverhead property as a laboratory headed by Beverage for research on receivers and long-wire receiving antennas. Alexanderson, Reoch and Taylor in their journal article (Ref. 5) cited the following considerations in selecting the Rocky Point site for the location of the transmitters and the primary Radio Central site: “1. The site must be within a reasonable distance from New York-the center of traffic. 2. A large tract of land of a desirable nature must be available at a moderate cost. 3. A good power supply must be within easy reach. (Probably at the time, the Long Island Lighting Company generating station, at Sea Cliff.) 4. There must be direct and reliable wire line communication with New York City.” Another consideration not cited in the article was the need for physical separation between the transmitters and receivers to prevent interference for which the Barrage receivers were installed as described earlier.

What features set this work apart from similar achievements?

Introduction

Occupying 9000 acres at two locations with 200KW transmitters, RCA Radio Central in 1922 was characterized as both the largest and most powerful communications station at the time. Its design linked transmitting facilities at Rocky Point and receiving facilities at Riverhead, through a system of relays utilizing existing telephone lines, controlled from its Central Traffic Office in New York City. The system marked the first time such widely separated communications facilities were controlled from a remote location.

The Facilities

Rocky Point

The three main operations buildings at Rocky Point were designated Bldg#1, Bldg#9 and Bldg#10. Figure 2 shows their locations.

Figure 2. Building Locations on RCA Radio Central Property, (Pine Barrens Preserve).

Building #1 (Fig. 3) was the administration and operations building. The original two Alexanderson Alternators were installed in the building and with the subsequent shift to shortwave operations in the 3-6.7 MHz frequency range more than 80 tube transmitters with power ratings up to 40 KW were also installed. The two story building design was based on Spanish architecture. The control room for transmissions was on the main floor. The fountain and pool in front of the building were both decorative and functional. The jets seen in the photo maintained the pool’s water reservoir used for cooling the Alexanderson Alternators.

Figure 3. Building #1, Administration & Transmitting Building.

Building #9 (Fig. 4) was built to accommodate additional transmitters to meet increased demand for point-to-point circuits and to provide backup for the subsequent tube transmitters in Building #1. It was located about 1.2 miles east of Bldg#1 (Fig.2). It was a two story Art Deco design building with decorative panels inside and related designs on the outside walls.

Figure 4. Building #9, HF Transmitters & Building #1 Backup.

Bldg#10 (Fig. 5), the Research and Development Laboratory, originally headed by Harold Beverage, was at the southern end of the Rocky Point property (Fig.2). Compared with the architectural designs of Buildings #1 and #9, it was unimpressive. The initial work carried out in the building was the design of the long wave antenna towers, grounding systems and relaying technology and later, for HF vacuum tube transmitters and antennas.

Figure 5. Building #10, Research & Development Laboratory.

Riverhead

RCA’s first research laboratory established by Harold Beverage in October 1919 at Riverhead was in a tent on what is now the 2000 acre David Sarnoff Preserve. It was at Riverhead that the experimental work leading to the development of the long wire Beverage directional antenna was developed and became the basis for the receiving part not only of Radio Central but for all RCA wireless receiving. From the very beginning, it was planned to incorporate Beverage’s work and facilities as part of Radio Central’s receiving facilities.

The original wooden permanent building was no longer adequate. A second brick building which included frequency measuring equipment was built in 1922 (Fig. 6).

Figure 6. Riverhead Receiving Building. Harold Beverage in Center.

Central Traffic Office, New York City

All of the messages sent from Radio Central in Rocky Point were controlled from the Central Traffic Office (Fig. 7) at 64 Broad Street in New York City. Incoming messages to the office for transmission arriving via telephone lines, hand-written or typed, were retyped on to a punch tape in Morse code and then sent over telephones lines to Radio Central at up to 200 words per minute, more than five times the usual speed using semi-automatic telegraph keys. Receivers monitored the signal transmitted from Rocky Point. In the central traffic office were six transoceanic receivers, six local monitoring receivers and six automatic tape transmitters. One-fifth of the telegraphic communications between the United States and Europe passed through the central traffic office (Ref. 2).

Figure 7. Central Traffic Office.

Transmitters

When construction of Radio Central started vacuum tubes were already being used by ham radio operators and researchers as oscillators and amplifiers at the lower short wave frequencies, while very low frequency high power Alexanderson Alternators were being used at a number of stations to provide reliable transmissions. With two new Alexanderson alternators transferred from Marconi to RCA and Alexanderson acknowledging that while acknowledging the short waves had an advantage for distances less than 3000 miles because of their low “absorption,” for longer distances, wavelengths over 11,000 meters provided the greater reliability, the choice of the alternators was preferred.

It was planned to install twelve 200KW Alexanderson Alternators at 18.2KHz with twelve radial configured directional antennas (Fig. 8) to provide not only reliable around the clock transoceanic communications with Europe, but with the world.

Figure 8. Planned Directional Antenna Configuration

Only two of the Alexanderson Alternators were installed and operational. By the time Radio Central was completed short wave transmitters had become available at a fraction of the cost of a Alexanderson alternator. It had cost General Electric $1 Million to develop the alternator for Marconi. Marshall Etter (Ref. 3) stated that, “It was a good thing they didn’t build the rest………would’ve been obsolete and RCA would have been in serious financial trouble.” The two alternators remained in service until the 1950s. During WW2, modifications were made to permit their keying from Washington, DC. as the long wavelengths permitted communications with submarines while submerged. The two alternators were installed in Building #1, the Administration Building. Subsequently 80 HF transmitters with power ratings up to 40 KW were also installed in the building. Transmissions included telegraph frequency shift keying, single side-band and double side-band carrier modulation. With the need to accommodate additional point- to- point transmitting circuits, Building #9 was built with a small cooling pond for 24 transmitters operating in the 3.0 to 30 MHz frequency bands with up to 55 KW ratings. Power for the Rocky Point facility was provided by the Long Island Lighting Company: 23,000 volts, three phase 60 cycle current to a substation that was on the road to Building #1. Emergency power was available at both buildings, 225KW at Building #1 and 250KW at Building #9.

Receivers

With the decision to build Radio Central, the Riverhead site became the central receiving location for the Radio Central complex with Harold Beverage in charge of developing receivers.

The receivers were adaptations of his “Barrage Receiver,” (Ref.17) which differed in several respects from other systems that had been used in transatlantic communication. They represented a significant improvement in the reception of receiving radio messages by being able to tune out interfering stations. In his 1919 paper, (“The Barrage Receiver,” Transoceanic Radio Communication, Telegraph and Telephone Age,) Alexanderson described it as a fundamentally unidirectional receiver that required an aperiodic antenna with regard to the receiving frequencies of interest. There were six Barrage receivers installed in the original wooden building (Fig.10).

The Barrage receiver was a modified standard radio design consisting of two sections as shown in Figure 9. The first section contained a double set of phase rotators to null out interfering received signals, the second section was a standard audion triode detector amplifier. While the Barrage receiver was developed primarily to avoid interference from stations during transoceanic operations, it was found to reduce coupling when simultaneously sending and receiving from small shore or ship stations. It also helped to minimize interference from co-located transmitters at the same location.

Figure 9. Circuit Diagram of Barrage Receiver.
Figure 10. Six Long Wave Barrage Receivers at Riverhead.

Riverhead began operations with four of the Barrage receivers shown in Figure 10 with provision to install as many as nine. While only two were required for the initial Alexanderson alternators, the others were used for other Radio Central stations. The first section of each receiver consisted of double phase rotators (Fig. 9), followed by three stages of RF amplification, a detector and two stages of audio amplification. Among subsequent receiver development started at Riverhead in the early twenties by Beverage and H.O. Peterson was the diversity receiver to compensate fading of short-wave signals by separating receivers and their antennas. They patented their work in 1931(Ref.18) and in 1933 built and demonstrated a triple diversity receiver. By the late twenties, 41 triple-diversity receivers had been installed at Riverhead for communications with 26 different countries.

Transmitting Antennas

Alexanderson was RCA’s first chief engineer and responsible not only for the installation of the alternators but also the design of the antennas. At the time the prevailing concept was that operating at the very low frequencies permitted reception over longer distances and with greater reliability. Wireless stations at the time used vertical antennas, because of the very long wavelengths and required heights, full size resonant antennas could not be built. The vertical antennas used were electrically short and inefficient in terms of the power radiated relative to the transmitter’s input power. Alexanderson, while with General Electric addressed the design of an efficient antenna for very low frequency operations and in 1920 obtained a patent (#217379) for a flat top antenna tunable to multiple frequencies.

Figure 10. Alexanderson Antenna Schematic,1920.

At rocky Point he and his associates adapted his original flat-top antenna system for use with the high power very low frequency alternators. It consisted of six 410 foot steel towers (Fig. 11) with 150 foot crossbeams on which were mounted 12 parallel wires, 14 feet apart, that extended for 7500 feet in length with loading coils (Fig. 12. Note size relative to figure.) to provide tuning for operating at different carrier frequencies and for matching the antenna impedance to the transmitter. The counterpoise ground for the antenna consisted of buried wires that were the equivalent of a copper plate 2000 feet wide and three miles long. (Ref 2, p697.)

Figure 11. Transmitting Antenna Towers.
Figure 12. Antenna Loading Coils.

Receiving Antennas.

There were two principal types of antennas when Radio Central started operations in 1922. The antenna for the Barrage Receivers which consisted of two insulated wires laid on the ground a distance of two miles in each direction from the receiving station and the Beverage antenna..

Beverage who had worked at G.E. with Alexanderson while he was developing the flat top antenna for transmitters had been at the RCA Riverhead location since 1919 working on directional wave antennas. By 1921 he had installed experimental long wave antennas nine miles long, so when Radio Central opened in 1922 he had two long wave directional antennas working, one nine miles long and the other 7 miles long and only 30 feet above ground. In 1921 and 1922, he had received four patents (Ref.18) based on his original design in which one end of the antenna was pointed in the direction of the received signal, terminated in a resistor to ground and the other end connected to the receiver with a matching circuit for the antenna’s characteristic impedance.

Research, Development and Firsts

Research and development at Radio Central was carried out over the many years of its operation, initially in support of very low frequency communications operations and subsequently in the applications of electronics. As vacuum tubes were developed for transmitters and receivers operating at the short wave frequencies that could provide reliable communications using relatively low power, smaller antennas and at less equipment costs, the research and development focus shifted accordingly.

The work carried out in the Research and Development Laboratory (Building #10.) was originally under the direction of Harold Beverage who started the first RCA lab at the Riverhead site. He was succeeded by Clarence Hansell in 1925 who among his many patents resulting from his work at the lab was one on Piezo-electric crystals (Patent #1874980) and another on the transmission of images over bundles of glass fibers (Calvo, Maria,“Optical Waveguides”, Introduction, CRC Press, 2007). During the time he was in charge, 1925-29, the emphasis of the laboratory was in developing and placing in service the transmitting facilities with which RCA was able to maintain its leadership in the world-wide public service radio communications business. In 1929 the work of the laboratory was taken over by RCA Communications, Inc. and in 1942 by RCA Laboratories in 1942.

Philip Carter, who was at the laboratory, designed the tower structures and grounding system used with the Alexanderson alternators and developed long-wire antennas for high frequencies. As part of his antenna research he developed the folded-wave antenna used at the short wave frequencies.

Nils Lindenblad, also at the lab designed the original NBC television antenna installed atop the Empire State Building in 1938 and Ludwig Batterman who worked with him invented the coaxial cable connector (Patent #2153527) that permitted matched cable impedances eliminating standing wave reflections.

The Diversity receiver developed at the Riverhead facility by Beverage and Peterson was described in the Receivers section above.

In January of 1923 the first experimental single-sideband (one way) transmitting and receiving station communication occurred between Radio Central at Rocky Point and New South Gate, near London. The system operating at 57 KHz was set up by Bell System research engineers with Radio Central (Fig. 13). It was publicly demonstrated and with the support of the British Post Office led to the establishment of the first commercial New York (Rocky Point) to London circuit in 1927. It was described in the December 1956, Proceedings of the IRE, by Arthur Oswald.

Figure 13. SSB Generator Experiment Set-up in 1922 at Rocky Point.

RCA was the first company to adapt facsimile to radio, and sent a transoceanic image of President Calvin Coolidge from New York via Radio Central to London on November 29, 1924. Two years later it began a commercial service of transmitting transoceanic photos by shortwave radio for the newspaper industry transmitting weather maps to ships at sea. RCA’s patented “Photoradio” technology was invented by RCA scientists Richard H. Ranger and Charles J. Young. (Coopersmith, Jonathan, “FAXED, The Early Rise and Fall of the FAX Machine,” JHU Press, 2015) It used a rotating drum and a photoelectric scanner to convert a document into a continuous tone that varied in pitch with changes in the image. The image was reproduced on the receiving end with another rotating drum having a stylus that pressed black carbon paper against white paper to reproduce the image.

General Electric performed the first experiments with high power vacuum tube transmitters at Rocky Point using an Alexanderson alternator running at low power as an exciter for GE’s tube transmitters. The success of these experiments contributed to the development of high power tubes and the demise of the alternator.

Early frequency shift keying trials were performed using an Alexanderson alternator at Rocky Point to send the "mark" signals and another alternator at Tuckerton, New Jersey to send the "spaces." It proved unwieldy for regular use, but demonstrated its merits.

Supporting texts and citations to establish the dates, location, and importance of the achievement: Minimum of five (5), but as many as needed to support the milestone, such as patents, contemporary newspaper articles, journal articles, or chapters in scholarly books. 'Scholarly' is defined as peer-reviewed, with references, and published. You must supply the texts or excerpts themselves, not just the references. At least one of the references must be from a scholarly book or journal article. All supporting materials must be in English, or accompanied by an English translation.


Supporting materials (supported formats: GIF, JPEG, PNG, PDF, DOC): All supporting materials must be in English, or if not in English, accompanied by an English translation. You must supply the texts or excerpts themselves, not just the references. For documents that are copyright-encumbered, or which you do not have rights to post, email the documents themselves to ieee-history@ieee.org. Please see the Milestone Program Guidelines for more information.

To be provided.

Please email a jpeg or PDF a letter in English, or with English translation, from the site owner(s) giving permission to place IEEE milestone plaque on the property, and a letter (or forwarded email) from the appropriate Section Chair supporting the Milestone application to ieee-history@ieee.org with the subject line "Attention: Milestone Administrator." Note that there are multiple texts of the letter depending on whether an IEEE organizational unit other than the section will be paying for the plaque(s).

Please recommend reviewers by emailing their names and email addresses to ieee-history@ieee.org. Please include the docket number and brief title of your proposal in the subject line of all emails.